02 Dec Central Mass. employers tackle mental health stigma
Worcester Business Journal Online.Com, December 2, 2015, Central Massachusetts Health
BY LIVIA GERSHON, SPECIAL TO CENTRAL MASSACHUSETTS HEALTH
Paul Fontaine is studying communications at Worcester State University, and he also recently got a part-time job working for a UMass Medical School office in Shrewsbury. But he says none of this would have been possible if it weren’t for Genesis Club, a Worcester organization dedicated to helping people with psychiatric diseases with education, wellness, and employment.
“Alcoholism and mental illness has been in my father’s side of my family for two generations, and I didn’t want to be generation number three,” he said. “If I didn’t take meds I would not be the same person, and probably become a bad person-kind of like Jekyll and Hyde in reverse, where if you don’t take your meds you become a beast.”
Beyond controlling his illness through medication, Fontaine said being able to do productive work has been a key to his recovery. This is why it’s not much of a surprise that so many businesses have started to invest in things like the best office desks (to help their workers feel more comfortable whilst they are working), as well as on-going support to create a productive work environment. In order for Fontaine to be productive at work, he’s been a member of the Genesis Club since 2008, finding opportunities for work and employment through the group.
“It’s been tremendous,” he said. “I’m one of those individuals that just can’t not work.”
Fontaine said he’s had great experiences with his jobs. But he said there’s still a big social stigma in the larger society around having a psychiatric illness.
“I’ve heard people say things about people with mental illness that they would never say if the person had a physical illness: ‘Suck it up, you’re just being moody,'” he said. “Society is making progress with it, but we still have a long way to go.”
In Central Massachusetts, there’s a growing awareness of how important this issue is. Employers, workers and mental health professionals are increasingly speaking out about the need for better systems to address mental health on the job. Many employers are working the employee benefits they have that can offer assistance in this area into their HR systems to help provide better access for workers.
Genesis Club alone helps more than 750 people each year get assistance with education, wellness, and employment. Executive Director Kevin Bradley said that last year, 171 members like Fontaine returned to work or found jobs for the first time.
“Throughout their recovery, most of them have been told that they’re unable to work by the system, by friends or family, and the medical profession,” he said. “We don’t actually pay any attention to that. When members come into the club it’s such a work-focused environment with members and staff working together that they start to see some confidence come back as far as employment.”
To help members make the jump back into the working world, Genesis Club offers a transitional employment program. Members work part-time, with the clubhouse offering support and training. Clubhouse staff also train for the job so that they’re able to provide coverage if a member’s illness forces them to be absent. Some clubhouse members are young adults who might have assumed they’d never be able to hold a job. Others are trying to figure out how to return to work after a major episode of illness.
Bradley said the clubhouse works with about 35 employers in the Worcester area, including the Worcester Art Museum, Saint-Gobain and food service companies that serve local colleges.
Breaking down barriers
Bill Tsaknopoulos, director of auxiliary services at UMass Medical School, is in charge of food service, mailroom and janitorial areas that employ Genesis Club members.Tsaknopoulos said the club members, which presently total 22, are typically good workers eager to earn a living and be respected for the work they do. And he said a bonus for the school is that the workers’ presence helps dismantle stereotypes that others on campus sometimes hold.
“We started breaking down these barriers for our staff,” he said. “I’ve seen them become teammates, partners in trying to get the jobs done.”
Finding and keeping work can be a serious problem for many people with psychiatric diseases. The National Alliance on Mental Illness has found that the unemployment rate among people getting public mental health services is about 80 percent.
A drain on productivity?
Meanwhile, those who have stable jobs face their own set of challenges. A recent report by NAMI’s Massachusetts chapter found that one of the greatest impediments to workplace productivity is psychiatric illness, particularly depression. According to its analysis, mental health conditions accounted for 62 percent of the days that workers were unable to do their jobs. Adding up absences, medical care and lost productivity, the report finds depression incurs the highest total cost across the economy of all mental and physical disorders.
Part of the reason that mental illness can be more expensive than physical disease is that it’s more likely to go unaddressed. NAMI finds that the biggest costs of mental illness come from “presenteeism,” the situation where workers show up but are too ill to perform at their best. When that happens, employees may not want to bring up psychiatric problems with their bosses or human resource departments, while supervisors may not know how to broach the subject even if they notice a worker is struggling. It is hoped that through progressive company culture, more employees will be able to share their problems with their employers and be able to get the support they need. It helps that more businesses are outsourcing their HR to outsider HR Consultancy Firms that will allow any complaints or issues more professionally. An employee is more likely to share their issue if they know the matter will be dealt with professionally.
Stephen Rosenfeld, president of NAMI Massachusetts, said an honest conversation with a manager can help an employee find the support they need. Without it, they may continue to suffer, believing they need to hide their illness.
“Things just evolve and get worse from there,” he said.
Rosenfeld said the problem is not that CEOs are actively creating a stigmatizing environment for workers with psychiatric illnesses but that they don’t fully understand the issue.
“It’s inattention,” he said. “It’s just not appreciating the impact of stigma, and also not being sure what can be done about it.”
CEOs stand up against stigma
That’s by NAMI Massachusetts launched a “CEOs Against Stigma” campaign this June. The idea is to provide leadership at the top of organizations to address the obstacles that people with psychiatric disorders sometimes face at work.
The campaign asks CEOs who sign up to pledge to do several very specific things, including opening communication with their workforce about the issue, making sure their company offers strong mental health benefits, and helping inform other CEOs about the program. It also asks them to bring NAMI’s “In Our Own Voice” presentations, in which people who have lived with psychiatric problems telling their own stories about life on the job.
Joyce Murphy, CEO of Commonwealth Medicine, the Shrewsbury-based consulting division of UMass Medical School and an early signer of the CEOs Against Stigma pledge, recently helped organize these trainings for her employees.
“I had so many employees coming up, telling me it was really the most important training they had ever had,” said Murphy. “Many employees disclosed that they or family members had really struggled with mental illness.”
Like Murphy, Ed Manzi, CEO of Fidelity Bank in Leominster, was an early Central Massachusetts signer of the “CEOs Against Stigma” pledge. Fidelity has long done community service work aimed at addressing mental illness, helping to spearhead the SHINE Initiative, which supports mental health programs for young adults.
Manzi said he likes the” CEOs Against Stigma” approach because it’s backed by NAMI’s data about the prevalence and costs of mental illness.
“Most business leaders like to make decisions based on data, not just anecdotes,” he said.
To Manzi, the point of the effort is straightforward: to make sure that mental illnesses are treated just like physical ones.
“Everyone experiences coworkers having the flu, strep throat, or something more serious,” he said. “This is just another type of health problems.”
Murphy echoed that sentiment, saying coworkers and managers should support an employee with a serious mental illness just like someone with cancer. They may need moral support, help with employee benefits and time off to seek treatment. If you are interested in finding out more about how to provide the best moral support and give the best benefits to your employees then you should take a look at something like this benefit administration software, this is particularly helpful if you work in a HR department.
If Commonwealth Medicine workers feel uncomfortable going to their supervisors with personal health issues, Murphy said, they can work with the human resources department and the organization’s employee assistance program. There are also licensed psychologists and social workers who can make sure workers get whatever assistance they need.
“I’m hoping people feel they can ask for help,” Murphy said. In addition to the importance of treating workers kindly and fairly, there’s also a simple calculus for employers when it comes to being open and helpful about mental illness, said Murphy,citing a statistic from a 2014 PricewaterhouseCoopers report that found every dollar spent addressing workers’ psychiatric disease leads to $2.30 in recovered productivity and other benefits to the employers. The report, based on an analysis of Australian employers, determined that effective interventions could reduce presenteeism, absenteeism and compensation by 33 percent.
Murphy said it’s clear that taking action on the job is a smart move for employers, employees and the people they serve.
“If we’re not looking out for our employees, we’re not going to be a good employer, and we’re not going to be able to achieve our mission very well,” she said.
Photo credit and caption: EDD COTE
Paul Fontaine, a member of Genesis Club in Worcester, said the club’s resources for people who suffer from mental illness have been crucial to his ability to work and pursue higher education.